Clean Air Won!!

Clean Air Won!! | 350 Contra Costa Action | A group of clean-air advocates in blue shirts stands outside the BAAD offices following the Board's November 4 decision for clean air in 2028 | Image credit: Coalition member, used with permission Bay Area Water Heater Rule Amended to Support Low-Income Households| 350 Contra Costa Action Bay Area Water Heater Rule Amended to Support Low-Income Households| 350 Contra Costa Action
Advocates who traveled to the BAAD offices in support of Rules 9-4 & 9-6 on November 4, 2026 | Image credit: Coalition member, used with permission

Bay Area Water Heater Rule Amended to Ease Costs for Low-Income Households

On November 4, 2026, fresh off the election-day “blue tsunami,” 350 Contra Costa Action joined other clean-air advocates to push changes to Rule 9-6, the Bay Area water heater rule. The Bay Area Air District (BAAD) adopted this landmark rule in 2023, with implementation scheduled for January 2027. Often cited as the boldest water heater standard in the U.S., the rule says that when old gas water heaters stop working, homeowners and businesses must replace them with electric ones. We were there to urge the Board to amend the rules to ease costs for low-income households.

Our goal: To help low-income families and businesses who might struggle to afford a new electric water heater when their old one breaks.

Wearing blue shirts, we stood shoulder to shoulder with advocates from eleven other organizations, all part of the Bay Area Clean Air (BACA) coalition, representing health, climate, and community interests across the region. Working together, as we have over the past year through letters, Zoom, and in-person meetings, we advocated for common-sense exemptions.

Our goal was to help low-income families and businesses who might struggle to afford a new electric water heater when their old one breaks. Equally important, we urged the Board to hold firm against fossil-fuel polluters pressing to scrap the rules altogether.

The November 4 decision is a victory for clean air and health for all San Francisco Bay Area residents.

Changes to Rule 9-6

The good news: The BAAD Board approved updates to Rule 9-6 to make the zero-NOx water heater standard more affordable while still delivering major public health benefits. (“Zero-NOx” means water heaters that don’t give off nitrogen oxides. NOx are pollutants that worsen air quality and contribute to serious health problems, such as asthma, heart disease, and premature death.)

The bad news: The Board also amended Rule 9-6 to take effect in January 2028, not January 2027, as originally scheduled. We argued that the four years since the rules were adopted were long enough to wait to begin saving lives and lowering energy and health care costs for Bay Area residents. The Board thought otherwise.

Nevertheless, the amended rule gives low-income property owners a break. We celebrate the Board’s adoption of this amendment. (See the full details at baaqmd.gov/building-appliances.)

What Rule 9-6 Does for Bay Area Residents

“Today, the Bay Area Air District said yes to saving lives and no to gas industry attempts to slow progress to clean our air. … This policy will show the rest of the country what’s possible,” said Fernando Gaytan, senior attorney at Earthjustice, in a Sierra Club press release.

Here’s what the new water heater rule means for the Bay Area:

When we stand together across cities and counties, we can effect meaningful change.

Still to come: Watch for alerts about proposed changes to BAAD’s Rule 9-4. This rule, originally intended to go into effect in January 2028, requires homeowners and businesses, when their aging system fails, to replace their worn-out gas-powered furnaces with energy-saving electric heat pumps.

Organizing Works!

This success required time and many hands. Earlier this year, we asked for your help to protect clean air in the Bay Area. Many of you stepped up. We couldn’t have done it without you. From sending in comments to speaking up at meetings to showing up in blue, your efforts made this win possible.

Thank you.


Pub. Nov. 16, 2026

— Share this page —